KPIHelm — Your KPIs. Our insight. Your future.
All articles

Google Shopping or Search: which one is actually making my Shopify store money?

You cannot tell from the account total or from the click-through rate. Split your campaigns by type, and for each type put three numbers side by side: what it spent, the store sales that came in through its ads, and the sales it needs to break even at your margin. A type whose sales stay above its own break-even line is paying for itself; one that stays below it is costing you money, whatever its return looks like inside Google Ads.

Most small Shopify stores on Google run two kinds of campaign at once: Shopping (or Performance Max, which shows Shopping ads too) and Search. The account overview adds them together, and the total hides almost everything that matters. In one small store we looked at, the combined click-through rate was 3.3%. Split by type, Shopping was at 1.65% and Search at 35.5%. Neither number is the 3.3%, and the 3.3% says nothing about which one earns money. The steps below take the two apart and give each its own verdict. For the same problem across Meta, Google and TikTok, see Your blended ROAS looks fine. One of your channels is losing money.

Step 1: Split the account by campaign type

Shopping and Search do different jobs, so they cannot share one verdict.

  • Add the campaign type to your table. In Google Ads, open Campaigns and add the "Campaign type" column, or filter by it. You want one line for Shopping, one for Search and one for Performance Max if you run it.
  • Shopping catches people who are browsing products. The ad is a picture, a price and your store name. Many people look, fewer click, and those who click already know what the product costs.
  • Search catches people who typed words. If those words are your store's name, the person was already looking for you.
  • Do not compare click-through rates across types. A Search ad on your own brand name gets a very high click-through rate because the person wanted to find you. A Shopping ad gets a much lower one by nature. A low Shopping rate next to a high Search rate is normal, not a sign that Shopping is failing.

Step 2: Find out how much of your Search is your own name

A Search campaign that mostly answers searches for your brand is doing something very different from one that finds new customers.

  • Open the search terms report for your Search campaign and sort by clicks. Count how many of the clicks came from searches containing your store's name.
  • Brand searches are people who already know you. Some of them would have clicked your normal listing under the ad and bought anyway. Their sales are real, but not all of them were created by the ad.
  • Product searches are closer to Shopping. Searches like "linen summer dress" bring people who did not know you yet, and they behave much more like Shopping clicks.
  • Keep this split in mind for Step 5. A Search campaign that is 90% brand searches will almost always look better than Shopping. That does not make it the one to put more money into.

Step 3: Count the sales in your store, per campaign

Google Ads counts conversions by its own rules. For money decisions, use the orders your store recorded.

  • Your store can only credit a campaign it can see in the link. An order is tied to a campaign when the customer arrived by clicking an ad link that names that campaign. Google already adds a campaign number to its ad links. You can also add UTM tags for all campaigns at once with the "Final URL suffix" setting at account level.
  • Read these sales as "at least". A customer who saw the ad, left, and came back later by typing your address is not counted for any campaign. The real figure can be higher, never lower.
  • Use the same period for spend and sales. Take whole days, the same days on both sides, and at least two weeks. A few days of a small campaign is too little to judge.

Step 4: Work out each type's break-even line

A sale is not profit. Part of every sale pays for the product, the payment fee and the shipping. Only what is left can pay for the ad.

  • Find your break-even return. If 50% of every sale is left after product cost, payment fees and shipping, every €1 of ad spend needs €2 of sales just to break even. With 40% left, it needs €2.50. Your ROAS looks healthy. So why is there no money at the end of the month? shows how to work this out.
  • Turn it into a sales figure per type. Multiply each type's spend by your break-even return. If Shopping spent €300 and your break-even return is 2, Shopping needs €600 of sales to break even.
  • The line is the same for every type. Your costs do not change with the campaign, so only the spend moves the line.
  • Break even is not profit. Above the line the ads pay for themselves, but rent, salaries and your other fixed costs still have to be covered after that.

Step 5: Read the three numbers side by side

For each type you now have spend, store sales (at least) and the sales needed to break even. Compare them without dividing them into one ratio.

  • Sales above the line: this type is paying for itself on the sales your store can see. If it is a brand-heavy Search campaign, remember that part of those sales would have come anyway.
  • Sales below the line: this type is not paying for itself on the sales your store can see. Before you stop it, check whether a lot of its customers might come back later without the link, for example on another device. That is common with expensive products people think about for days.
  • Shopping below, Search above: do not simply move Shopping's budget to Search. Search on your name can only collect people who are already looking for you, and some of them first found you through Shopping. Lower Shopping by a part instead of stopping it, and watch your store's total sales for two weeks.
  • Both below: look at the store before the ads. Price, shipping cost and the product page decide whether a click becomes a sale on both types.

Step 6: Change one thing and read again

  • Change one campaign at a time, and leave it for at least two weeks before you judge it.
  • Read the same three numbers again for the same number of days before and after the change.
  • Judge by your store's total sales too. If one type's sales fall and the store's total does not, those sales probably moved to another type rather than disappearing.

KPIHelm's SUYLA plan puts this table on your Performance page every morning for a connected Google Ads account. Each campaign type (Shopping, Search, Performance Max and the others) gets one row that opens to its campaigns. Each row shows three figures side by side: ad spend, sales through its link (at least), counted from your Shopify orders that arrived through that campaign's ad link, and the sales needed to break even, calculated from the costs you entered in Settings. It does not divide them into one ratio. If you have not entered your costs, it asks for them instead of showing a break-even figure. Install it free on the Shopify App Store or see a sample report.